Top Fencing Companies in Shelter Island, NY, 11964 | Compare & Call

There are 25 fencing companies server in Shelter Island NY

wells contracting

wells contracting

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 / 5 (3)
Barker NY 14012
Roofing, Siding, Fences & Gates

Wells Contracting, based in Barker, NY, brings over 20 years of construction experience to every project. Our founder saw that many contractors lacked the passion and transparency homeowners deserve, ...

Protect-A-Child Pool Fence of Syracuse

Protect-A-Child Pool Fence of Syracuse

693 Masters Rd, Elbridge NY 13039
Pool & Hot Tub Service, Childproofing, Fences & Gates

Protect-A-Child Pool Fence of Syracuse serves Elbridge, NY, and the surrounding areas with specialized pool safety and fencing solutions. Located just minutes from the historic Elbridge Village Park a...

Sammys Pressure Wash & Staining

Sammys Pressure Wash & Staining

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 / 5 (1)
Auburn NY 13021
Painters, Fences & Gates, Decks & Railing

Sammys Pressure Wash & Staining is a family-owned business serving homeowners in Auburn, NY, and the surrounding area. With over 10 years of hands-on experience, we specialize in exterior house painti...

Rochester Landscape Designs

Rochester Landscape Designs

★★☆☆☆ 2.0 / 5 (1)
25 Charleswood Dr, Pittsford NY 14534
Landscaping, Fences & Gates, Landscape Architects or Designers

Rochester Landscape Designs, established in 2012, brings over 25 years of combined experience to the Pittsford area. Founded by a SUNY ESF graduate in Landscape Architecture, the company specializes i...

TWM Fencing

TWM Fencing

Le Roy NY 14482
Fences & Gates

TWM Fencing provides expert fence and gate services to homeowners in Le Roy, NY. From the historic Jell-O Museum district to the residential neighborhoods near Oatka Creek Park, local properties face ...

Baker Brothers Homes Improvement

Baker Brothers Homes Improvement

Irondequoit NY 14617
General Contractors, Roofing, Fences & Gates

Baker Brothers Home Improvements is a small, locally-owned general contracting business serving Irondequoit, NY, and the surrounding areas. We specialize in a wide range of home improvement projects i...

Wash Rescue

Wash Rescue

Rochester NY 14604
Roofing, Siding, Fences & Gates

Wash Rescue serves homeowners throughout Rochester, NY, providing professional cleaning for roofs, siding, fences, and gates. The team understands that Rochester’s weather—from heavy lake-effect snow ...

KD Fence & Deck Services

KD Fence & Deck Services

1387 Dewey Ave, Rochester NY 14613
Fences & Gates, Decks & Railing

KD Fence & Deck Services, based in Rochester, NY, provides expert installation, repair, and maintenance for fences and decks. Specializing in addressing local challenges like frost heave—which causes ...

J&J Fencing

J&J Fencing

★★★★★ 5.0 / 5 (1)
Livonia NY 14487
Fences & Gates

J&J Fencing is a family-owned fencing company based in Livonia, NY, serving homeowners across the Greater Rochester and Buffalo areas. We specialize in the installation and repair of wood, vinyl, chai...

Corner Post Fence

Corner Post Fence

Rochester NY 14626
Fences & Gates

Corner Post Fence brings over a decade of experience to fence and gate projects in Rochester, NY. Serving neighborhoods from Brighton to Greece, we specialize in vinyl, chain link, aluminum, and wood ...



Estimated Fencing Costs in Shelter Island, NY

Emergency Fence/Gate RepairStorm / Security Response
$329 - $444
Wood Privacy Fence (Per LF)Estimated Range
$29 - $44
Vinyl / PVC Fencing (Per LF)Estimated Range
$44 - $64
Chain Link Installation (Per LF)Estimated Range
$19 - $29
Aluminum / Ornamental (Per LF)Estimated Range
$49 - $69
Standard Driveway Gate InstallEstimated Range
$1,184 - $1,589

Methodology: Estimates are dynamically generated using localized construction labor multipliers derived from 2025 BLS OEWS (SOC 47-4031) data for Shelter Island. Prices reflect standard commercial/residential material specs and labor options adjusted for 2026 economic projections.

Questions and Answers

How do modern gate systems meet both security trends and New York's pool code?

The moderate smart-gate trend integrates IoT-controlled, self-closing and self-latching mechanisms. These systems meet NYS Uniform Code Part 1220, which mandates a 48-inch minimum height and automatic latching for pools. An integrated smart latch provides access logs and remote status checks, fulfilling modern liability standards for New York homeowners.

What are the critical steps before any excavation for a fence project?

You must contact New York 811 at least 2 full business days before digging. In Shelter Island Heights, with its older utility infrastructure, hitting a buried line is a major liability. The service provides public utility locates. Concurrently, submit plans to the Town Building Department for a permit, especially if you are in the Shelter Island Heights Historic District, which requires ARB approval.

What are the height and placement rules for fences on Shelter Island, especially near roads?

Zoning limits are 4 feet in front yards and 6 feet in rear/side yards. The setback regulation is 0 feet, allowing installation on the property line. For corner lots, especially those near NY-114, you must maintain a clear 'sight triangle' at intersections. No visual obstruction is permitted within 10 feet of the property corner to ensure driver visibility.

What fencing materials are suitable for Shelter Island's soil and pest conditions?

Shelter Island has moderate soil corrosivity and a moderate termite risk level. Use hot-dip galvanized or powder-coated steel posts and fasteners. For wood, specify pressure-treated lumber rated for ground contact. Aluminum or composite materials are also viable. Avoid untreated wood and standard steel fasteners, which will rust and create corrosive streaks.

Why do fence posts in Shelter Island Heights fail prematurely, and what is the correct installation standard?

Posts fail from frost heave. The Shelter Island frost line depth is 30 inches. The 2021 IRC requires post footings to extend below this depth to prevent uplift. Posts set in shallow concrete will heave during freeze-thaw cycles, compromising the entire structure's stability and alignment.

What are my legal obligations to my neighbor when replacing a fence on our shared property line?

New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law Section 843, the 'Good Neighbor Fence Law,' requires written notice to adjoining owners 30 days before work begins on a shared boundary. In Shelter Island, this 2026 requirement is critical for establishing cost-sharing and preventing disputes. Provide plans and a cost estimate with your notice.

How is a fence engineered to withstand Shelter Island's high wind loads?

The design wind speed for Shelter Island is 135 MPH V-ult. This ultimate wind load rating, per ASCE 7-22 standards, dictates post spacing, concrete footing size, and bracket strength. A standard 6-foot fence in an exposed area near the ferry terminal may require posts spaced 6 feet on center with reinforced concrete piers to survive peak storm season gusts without racking or failure.

What is the typical timeline and process for starting a fencing project on Shelter Island?

After a signed agreement, we schedule utility locates and permit submission. For an initial consultation, our team routes from the Shelter Island Ferry Terminal via NY-114. Accounting for ferry schedules and island traffic, plan for a 45-60 minute response window for us to be on-site. The labor rate for skilled installation averages $45 per hour.



Scroll to Top
CALL US NOW